Dave Aranda finished his Baylor run at 40-40. You genuinely cannot be more middle-of-the-road than that. Baylor fired him Oct. 25, the day after a 25-24 loss to Kansas, and to be fair to the guy, he did win a Big 12 title in 2021. Then everything after 2021 happened.

Naturally, the team got better the second he left. Joe Klanderman took over, won his first two games, then went to Provo and got smacked 28-7 by BYU. So Baylor’s 6-4, bowl eligible, and running a coaching search on the side like it’s no big deal.
NC State already went and hired Philip Rivers, so it’s basically Baylor and Florida State left as the good jobs. FSU has more money. Baylor has RG3 asking for the job on national radio. I know which one I’d rather write about.
Next Baylor Coach Odds
| Coach | Current Job | Odds | Implied Probability |
| Jeff Traylor | UTSA HC | +175 | 36.4% |
| Robert Griffin III | Fox Sports analyst | +350 | 22.2% |
| Joe Klanderman | Baylor interim HC | +600 | 14.3% |
| GJ Kinne | Texas State HC | +700 | 12.5% |
| Zach Kittley | FAU HC | +1000 | 9.1% |
| Shannon Dawson | Miami OC | +1400 | 6.7% |
| Lincoln Riley | USC HC | +2000 | 4.8% |
| Spencer Danielson | Boise State HC | +2500 | 3.8% |
| Jake Dickert | Wake Forest HC | +3000 | 3.2% |
Odds via Mr. Gamble’s own handicapping as of Nov. 18, 2026. Not a sportsbook market.
Jeff Traylor (+175)
Traylor is the name I keep landing on, and I’m not alone, he’s at the top of just about every Baylor list floating around. He’s from Gilmer, he coached Texas high school ball for years, and he probably has half the high school coaches in the state saved in his phone. For a school that lives and dies with Texas recruiting, that matters a lot.
He’s also just a good coach. Two straight C-USA titles in 2021 and 2022, a 12-2 year in there, and UTSA was 7-2 going into last weekend. They’re 33-5 at the Alamodome under him, which makes a trip there about as fun for road teams as a dentist appointment.
The problem is he keeps saying no. Texas Tech tried, other schools tried, and he’s signed in San Antonio through 2031. Traylor has turned down more jobs than most of us have applied for. But Baylor has real NIL money and this might be the best Power 4 job he ever gets a crack at, so I think he finally bites.
-
Exclusive code: MRGAMB
Deposit $20 Get $5018+ Only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Not available in all jurisdictions. Trading is risky. 100% loss can occur. See polymarket.com/tos for more information. The Polymarket US App serves as an independent software provider and affiliate of Polymarket US and Polymarket Clearing, the CFTC-regulated exchange and clearing organization. -
Exclusive code: MRGAMB
Deposit $10, Get $50 in Trade CreditsRestrictions & requirements apply. Not available in all states. 21+. Event contract trading involves risk & is not appropriate for all. Consider if it's appropriate for you in light of financial circumstances. See novig.com/terms for information. Restrictions & requirements apply. Not available in all states. 21+. Event contract trading involves risk & is not appropriate for all. Consider if it's appropriate for you in light of financial circumstances. See novig.com/terms for information. -
Exclusive code: MRGAMBLE
Trade $10, Get $2018+. T&C Apply. Play Responsibly -
Trade $25, Get $25
Robert Griffin III (+350)
No, this isn’t a bit. Griffin went on The Dan Patrick Show right after Aranda got canned, said he was “100 percent” interested and mentioned he’d already talked to AD Doug McNamee. Then On3 reported last Friday that Baylor is actually going to interview him.
Look, I get it. He’s the only Heisman winner in school history and McLane Stadium would sell out for his first practice. But his coaching résumé right now is, uh, Fox Sports. He hasn’t coached a single college game, not even as a position coach.
Kalshi actually had him slightly ahead of Traylor last week at around 38-39%. Before you run with that, there’s maybe a few hundred bucks in that market. One guy at a bar in Waco could move it. We’ve got RG3 second, because an interview is not an offer. Then again, NC State just handed Rivers the keys, so I’ve stopped saying never.
Joe Klanderman (+600)
Klanderman deserves real credit here. He beat UCF 41-9 and Iowa State 42-31 in his first two games, and his defense has been sacking quarterbacks like it’s personal. Heading into BYU they were No. 2 in the country in sacks and No. 3 in tackles for loss.
He’s got four FCS titles from North Dakota State, he’s said he’d love the job, and he’s said he won’t campaign for it mid-season. RG3 has endorsed him too. Yes, the same RG3 who’s also interviewing for it. College football is great.
Then BYU happened, and that didn’t help. Baylor also seems to want an offensive guy with Texas ties, which he isn’t. Beat Texas Tech and Houston and we’ll talk. For now he’s +600.
GJ Kinne (+700)
Kinne checks a lot of the boxes people keep talking about. Texas guy, offensive guy, knows the state. He played QB at Tulsa, won at Incarnate Word, and now has Texas State in the Pac-12. A few years ago that last sentence would have gotten you laughed out of the room.
He’s 3-0 in bowl games in San Marcos and learned from guys like Doug Pederson, Gus Malzahn and Chip Kelly. The knock is a 12-12 conference record coming into this season, and he’s locked up through 2031 just like Traylor. Lot of 2031 contracts on this board.
Zach Kittley (+1000)
Kittley is reportedly on Baylor’s short list. Texan, Texas Tech guy, and he made his name calling plays before he got the FAU job. He also coached Caden Veltkamp, if that means anything to you.
Year one at FAU was 4-8. Yikes. They were 6-3 as of last week though, so things are trending the right way. He’d be a swing, but a fun one.
The Rest of the Board
Shannon Dawson (+1400) is third on Kalshi at around 5-6%. Miami OC since 2023, Air Raid guy, spent years at Houston with Dana Holgorsen. He’s been linked to so many head coaching jobs that he probably keeps an interview suit pressed at all times. Hasn’t landed one yet.
Lincoln Riley (+2000) is only on here if USC cuts him loose, and beating No. 2 Ohio State 30-18 on Halloween bought him a lot of time. He’s a Texan with Big 12 history and Baylor’s reportedly interested, but his buyout is around $70 million. That’s a lot of Dr Pepper, even in Waco.
RG3 also endorsed Spencer Danielson (+2500). Boise State is 8-1 and chasing a Pac-12 title, and Danielson says he’s staying. And coaches never say that and then leave two weeks later. Never.
Jake Dickert (+3000) is the most popular guy at every hot board party right now. He’s also our Florida State favorite, and if both come calling, I’m guessing he picks the Seminoles.
Why This Search Is Different
This is Doug McNamee’s first big hire. He became AD in December 2025, he’s a Baylor alum, and he spent most of his career outside athletics. Translation: nobody really knows what he’s going to do, possibly including him.
Most of the reporting says Baylor wants an offensive coach who knows Texas high school football. That’s Traylor, Kinne and Kittley, and it’s why we have Traylor on top even though Kalshi had Griffin a nose ahead.
Still, don’t sleep on RG3. Once NC State hired Rivers, a famous alum with zero college head coaching experience stopped being a punchline. Baylor fans would lose it.
When Will We Know?
Baylor has two games left. No. 10 Texas Tech comes to Waco this Saturday, then it’s a trip to Houston on Nov. 28.
If they land a sitting head coach like Traylor or Kinne, figure late November or early December once those seasons end. If it’s RG3 or Klanderman it could be quicker, since nobody needs permission from another school.
Either way, they need somebody in the chair before the transfer portal opens in January. Otherwise the new coach’s first job is recruiting his own roster back.
Responsible Gaming
Odds and implied probabilities reflect our own handicapping for informational and entertainment purposes only, not a licensed sportsbook market. Gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.