Next USMNT Coach Odds: B.J. Callaghan Leads, Pep Guardiola Isn’t Picking Up

U.S. Soccer is now back on the hunt, and the federation would like someone in place before the Nations League Finals in March. Here’s how our board shakes out.

Just three months after signing an extension to lead the USMNT through 2030, Poch bailed. Manchester United parted ways with head coach Michael Carrick last week and triggered the approximately $10 million release clause in Pochettino’s U.S. Soccer contract. He departed with a win, his side beating Haiti 2-0 in Cincinnati on Tuesday to seal an 8-0 aggregate result, with Pulisic adding a bicycle kick for good measure.

Next USMNT Coach Odds

CoachCurrent JobOddsImplied Probability
B.J. CallaghanNashville SC HC+25028.6%
Steve CherundoloUSMNT interim / U-23 HC+35022.2%
Pep GuardiolaUnattached+60014.3%
Pellegrino MatarazzoReal Sociedad HC+70012.5%
Thierry HenryUnattached+12007.7%
Mikey VarasSan Diego FC HC+14006.7%
Marko MitrovicNew England Revolution HC+20004.8%
Wilfried NancyUnattached+25003.8%
Gareth SouthgateUnattached+30003.2%

Odds via Mr. Gamble’s own handicapping as of Nov. 19, 2026. Not a sportsbook market.

B.J. Callaghan (+250)

Callaghan’s the guy, he’s earned it. The Nashville SC boss captured the U.S. Open Cup in 2025 before adding the Supporters’ Shield this season. He’s also held this post before, guiding the USMNT as interim in 2023 and lifting the Nations League trophy along the way. Players respond to him, Pulisic among them. It’s hardly a splashy hire, but after the previous coach walked out three months into a long-term deal, a manager who genuinely wants the gig carries real appeal.

Steve Cherundolo (+350)

Interim guy, could stick. Cherundolo will oversee the December camp, including a Dec. 13 friendly against Jamaica, while continuing in his role with the U-23s. He earned 87 caps as a player and, at LAFC, claimed the MLS Cup and Supporters’ Shield double in 2022 before winning the Open Cup in 2024. Critics did knock his LAFC sides for being overly defensive, though a strong camp would put him firmly in the frame.

Pep Guardiola (+600)

Not happening. Guardiola does have a soft spot for the States, having spent his post-Barcelona sabbatical in New York, and he’s been without a club since departing Manchester City in May. However, he stepped away citing burnout, and reports suggest he’s resisting U.S. Soccer’s approach. Fun to dream on, but that’s about it.

Pellegrino Matarazzo (+700)

Jersey guy, but happy in Spain. Matarazzo played his college soccer at Columbia, steered Real Sociedad to the Copa del Rey last season and was a finalist for this very job in 2024 before it went to Pochettino. He sounded lukewarm on the role in a spring interview with ESPN, and with a contract running in Spain, prying him loose mid-season figures to be difficult.

The Rest of the Board

Thierry Henry (+1200) has expressed a desire to manage a national team and is familiar with MLS from his stint in Montreal. Mikey Varas (+1400) handled two interim matches for the U.S. in 2024 and currently leads San Diego FC. Marko Mitrovic (+2000) worked with many of these young players at U-20 and U-23 level and lifted New England from 11th in the East to third this year. Wilfried Nancy (+2500) won MLS Cup with Columbus, while Gareth Southgate (+3000) is available, for what it’s worth.

When Will We Know?

Cherundolo holds the reins through the Jamaica friendly on Dec. 13, with the next competitive action arriving at the Nations League Finals at SoFi Stadium in March.

The federation wants this wrapped up before then. Should it land on an MLS coach such as Callaghan, the timing works out neatly with the season complete. If they’re still chasing Pep come February, though, good luck.


Odds and implied probabilities reflect our own handicapping for informational and entertainment purposes only, not a licensed sportsbook market. Gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER. This page might includes AI generated content. Our authors and experts always fact check the information we provide.

Manuel Mora Avatar

Written by

Newsletter

Subscribe to receive casino bonus updates

Get the latest casino bonuses, new casino alerts, and exclusive deals delivered straight to your inbox.

Something went wrong. Please try again.

Thanks for subscribing! Check your inbox for the latest updates.